Rare giant inguinal hernia causing end-stage dialysis-dependent renal failure

  1. Jacob Levi 1,
  2. Karl Chopra 1,
  3. Mubashar Hussain 2 and
  4. Shafiul Chowdhury 3
  1. 1 Accident and Emergency, Homerton University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK
  2. 2 General Surgery, Barts Health NHS Trust, London, UK
  3. 3 Urology, Barts Health NHS Trust, London, UK
  1. Correspondence to Dr Jacob Levi; jacob.levi@nhs.net

Publication history

Accepted:02 Apr 2020
First published:15 Apr 2020
Online issue publication:15 Apr 2020

Case reports

Case reports are not necessarily evidence-based in the same way that the other content on BMJ Best Practice is. They should not be relied on to guide clinical practice. Please check the date of publication.

Abstract

A 72-year-old man presented with urinary retention, weight loss, haematuria and severe acute kidney injury. He had never before been admitted to hospital and his past medical history included only an inguinal hernia. On examination, he appeared uraemic and had a right-sided painful hernia. A three-way catheter was inserted, bladder washouts performed and irrigation started. An ultrasound showed severe bilateral hydronephrosis and a ‘thickened bladder’ and this was thought to be obstructive uropathy secondary to bladder cancer. Twenty-four hours later his hernia doubled in diameter, became incarcerated and a CT of the abdomen and pelvis showed an inguinal hernia of both bladder and bowel, with the catheter tip inside the bladder hernia. He was taken to theatres and an open mesh repair was performed with a rigid cystoscopy to assist in locating and reducing the bladder. He required intensive care and dialysis postoperatively and remains on regular dialysis following discharge.

Background

Inguinal hernias are one of the most common surgical issues however only 1% to 3% of these hernias are of the bladder.1 A bladder hernia is often asymptomatic but may present with non-specific symptoms such as lower urinary tract symptoms or urinary tract infections.1 2 However, rare but severe complications of a bladder hernia include potentially life-threatening acute renal failure if not promptly treated.3 4

This report describes the case of a man that presented with haematuria, weight loss and urinary retention. His presentation was initially suspicious for an obstructing bladder cancer which impeded his true diagnosis. We think it is important that there is more awareness about this rare type of hernia as this will facilitate better management of patients with this condition, where early diagnosis and surgery may be able to prevent end-stage renal failure.

Case presentation

A 72-year-old man presented to Accident and Emergency at Newham University Hospital in 2019 with haematuria, nausea and vomiting, lethargy and weight loss. He had no cough, no chest pain, no fever, no dysuria, no night sweats and reported no pain. His past medical history involved only a right-sided inguinal hernia and he had no regular medications. He lived with his sister and reported no smoking or alcohol intake. On examination, he was thin, and his skin was pale and slightly yellow. He was afebrile and his observations were all normal, his chest was clear, heart sounds were normal and his abdomen was soft but tender in the epigastric area with reduced bowel sounds. He had a large painless reducible hernia in his right inguinal area.

Differential diagnosis

Initially the medical team caring for him were suspicious of an obstructive uropathy from a possible bladder tumour or malignancy due to his symptoms of weight loss, urinary retention and haematuria. This differential diagnosis was supported as initial investigations showed that he had a severe acute kidney injury and bilateral hydronephrosis with a thickened bladder wall. Only later did it become clear that his hernia was the cause of his urinary symptoms.

Investigations

He was found to be in a severe acute kidney injury (AKI) with a creatinine of 1305 μmol/L, urea of 46.8 mmol/L and estimated glomerular filtration rate of 3 mL/min/1.73 m2. His haemoglobin was 71 g/L, sodium was 135 mmol/L and potassium 5.5 mmol/L and infection markers were all normal. Chest radiograph was normal, abdominal radiograph showed an atypical bowel gas pattern but no signs of perforation. He was admitted under the medical team and started on intravenous (IV) fluids for his AKI. An ultrasound scan of the kidneys, ureters and bladder showed ‘bilateral gross hydroureteronephrosis with poor corticomedullary differentiation, no obstructing calculi’ were noted and the bladder wall was reported as ‘grossly thickened with slightly increased vascularity’. It was assumed that he had chronic bladder outflow obstruction, thought likely to be due to a malignancy.

At this point, he was referred to the urology team, a three-way catheter was inserted and bladder washouts performed and he was booked for a CT scan. A non-contrast CT scan of the urinary tract was done which showed that both kidneys were atrophic with severe hydronephrosis and hydro-ureters (up to 32 mm diameter) with perinephric stranding (figures 1 and 2).

Figure 1

Coronal view of CT abdomen and pelvis showing severe bilateral hydroureteronephrosis.

Figure 2

Axial view of CT abdomen and pelvis. *Catheter lumen inside bladder via urethra.

Furthermore, the CT showed that the inguinal hernia contained the bladder with the catheter in situ and a slightly enlarged prostate. It is likely that the ‘thickened bladder wall’ reported on ultrasound scan was actually the enlarged prostate due to the anatomical abnormality created by the large bladder hernia making the ultrasound images difficult to interoperate.

Overnight the hernia doubled in size, became erythematous, acutely tender and irreducible. He became more confused and was unable to present a reliable verbal history. At this point he stated to the surgeons that he’d had the hernia since he was 15 years old and it had not changed in size recently. However, a repeat non-contrast CT abdominal scan was performed which showed that the bladder had increased from 75 mm × 43 mm × 47 mm to a size of 135 mm × 110 mm × 130 mm and the catheter tip and balloon was no longer in the bladder and was now in the prostate preventing it from draining urine (see figure 3). The catheter balloon was deflated and pushed further into the bladder and re-inflated which allowed over 1 litre of urine to be drained and the hernia quickly shrunk and became reducible again. He was given more IV fluids and his AKI and uraemia started to resolve, as did his confusion and he explained that he had actually had the hernia for 15 years, not since he was 15 years old and that it had become acutely painful over the last couple of days. An urgent hernia repair was booked and the patient was taken to theatre that day.

Figure 3

Repeat CT abdomen and pelvis axial view. *Catheter tip obstructed and not reaching the bladder. White arrow pointing to bladder wall inside hernia.

Treatment

The patient was anaesthetised with a general anaesthetic and his right inguinal hernia was opened up (see figure 4). The small bowel hernia was found to be both direct and indirect (a pantaloon hernia) and the bladder was stuck to the bowel wall. A rigid cystoscopy was also performed at the time of the operation to help locate and reduce the bladder hernia and be sure there was no urine leak. A mesh repair was performed and the incision was closed.

Figure 4

Intraoperative photograph of reduction of bladder hernia.

Outcome and follow-up

He was transferred to the intensive care unit for recovery and dialysis and then was transferred to a tertiary care hospital for insertion of a tunnelled Vascath for further dialysis. A repeat ultrasound of the kidneys, ureters and bladder 3 weeks later showed the previously seen bilateral hydronephrosis had resolved significantly and the right kidney was now normal with no evidence of pelvicalyceal dilation and anteroposterior (AP) pelvic diameter was 8 mm which is within the normal range. The left kidney had mild pelvicalyceal clubbing and AP diameter was 12 mm. He was discharged 2 days later with three times per week dialysis to continue, however he continued to have complications such as secondary hyperparathyroidism, chronic anaemia and catheter-related infections and despite initial poor adherence with dialysis he is currently alive and well.

Discussion

The adage ‘common things are common’ is often repeated among medics and surgeons alike. Bladder hernias are rare and therefore often neglected by clinicians when considering the differential. In one review of 1950 patients undergoing groin hernia repairs in Turkey, the bladder was found in only 0.36% of groin hernias1 while other studies found up to 3% or 4% of inguinal hernias involve the bladder.5 A decade ago, a review found that only 7% of bladder hernias are diagnosed preoperatively.6 However, while diagnosis remains difficult, with the increasing use of CT scans nowadays, a review from 2018 found that 60% were diagnosed preoperatively.5 To prevent diagnostic difficulties and keep the differential net broad from the beginning, Karatzas et al state that bladder herniation should be considered in all patients that present with new onset renal impairment with an inguinal hernia.5 Bladder hernias are more common on the right side and most common in men over 50 who are overweight, however this is the same demographic group most at risk of all inguinal hernias.5 Most other cases presented with a swelling mass and lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS), however as with our case, it is common for men with bladder hernias to also have benign prostatic hyperplasia therefore it is difficult initially to tease apart which pathology is causing the LUTS.5 In certain advanced cases a two-stage urination process is reported, in which the hernia is manually compressed to aid urination, this is sometimes known as Mery’s sign.5 7–9

Diagnosis in our case was further complicated due to ultrasound imaging mistaking the enlarged prostate for the bladder. Ultrasound is susceptible to these errors as these scans are often very focussed and may not pay particular attention to areas not initially deemed to be of interest, for example, an inguinal hernia. There have been some cases where patients with bladder tumours were found to have incidental bladder hernias picked up on CT scans. Ultrasound is supported as an imaging modality by many groups4 7 8 but CT scan is most commonly used to accurately diagnose bladder hernias.5 In our case earlier CT imaging would have expedited the patient’s surgery, this view has been supported by Goonetilleke et al. 10

Cystoscopy is often used to aid planning of surgical approach.6 However, cystoscopy is of little diagnostic value and is not indicated in emergency presentations11 but can be useful to help avoid bladder injury5 and check intraoperatively for urinary leakage. Further diagnostic difficulty occurred in our case due to the uraemia and subsequent confusion of the patient, he was unable to clearly and consistently tell the clinicians looking after him about his symptoms and their duration, nor his medical history. This issue has not been reported in other published cases and reminds us to regularly check for cognitive impairment using a mini-mental state exam in elderly patients.

Very few cases of bladder hernia have presented with acute renal failure.4 7 10 12 13 Furthermore, to our knowledge this is only the second reported case of chronic dialysis dependant renal failure developing secondary to bladder herniation.13 The majority of cases are treated with preoperative percutaneous nephrostomies to allow for the correction of the renal failure before the operation.4 12 13 Three cases report the use of catheters to relieve obstruction and improve renal function preoperatively as was the situation in our case.9 10 In this case we again demonstrate that catheters can be used to de-obstruct the urinary tract instead of nephrostomies preoperatively. However, we want to emphasise that caution must be used, as in this case the catheter at one point became dislodged and temporarily caused worsening urinary obstruction and hernia strangulation until the catheter was repositioned deeper into the herniating bladder. Therefore, in these cases urine output, renal function, patient symptoms and clinical size of hernia need to be closely monitored to ensure patency of the catheter. Our case also highlights the use of cystoscopy at the time of surgery to aid emergency reduction of bladder hernias.

Learning points

  • Bladder hernias are extremely rare, and can become obstructed even with a catheter in situ if the catheter becomes compressed or kinked.

  • Delays in diagnosis and treatment of bladder hernias can ultimately lead to end-stage dialysis-dependant renal failure.

  • For patients presenting with acute kidney injury, an inguinal hernia and urinary obstruction, CT rather than ultrasound may be superior for expedited diagnosis in suspected bladder hernia cases.

  • To remember to do a dementia and delirium screen or cognitive assessment with all elderly patients and take a collateral history where possible and be wary of confusion due to uraemia in renal failure.

  • Bladder hernias can cause acute kidney injury, haematuria and end-stage dialysis-dependant chronic kidney disease if they are not treated quickly.

Footnotes

  • Contributors JL and KC wrote the manuscript with review and advice from SC and MH.

  • Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Patient consent for publication Obtained.

  • Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

References

Use of this content is subject to our disclaimer